As the seasons change, so do the rankings on the world’s largest creator platform. This September has brought some surprising shifts in the OnlyFans landscape, with established stars maintaining their dominance while new contenders emerge with revolutionary content strategies.
Our team has analyzed earnings data, subscriber growth rates, and social media impact to bring you this month’s undisputed champions. These creators aren’t just popular—they’re redefining what success looks like in the digital content industry.
1. Bella Thorne - The Eternal Trendsetter
September Earnings Estimate: $3.2M+
The Vibe: Mainstream celebrity meets boundary-pushing content creator
Why She’s #1: Bella continues to dominate with her unique blend of Hollywood glamour and authentic, intimate content. Her September rollout included a collaborative series with A-list directors, proving she’s still the platform’s creative innovator.
Where to Find Her: OnlyFans • Instagram • Twitter
2. Mia Khalifa - The Comeback Queen
September Earnings Estimate: $2.8M+
The Vibe: Unfiltered authenticity with intellectual flair
Why She’s Trending: Mia’s controversial podcast appearances and political commentary have driven massive traffic to her platform. Her “Uncensored Q&A” series has become must-see content, blending humor with hard truths about the industry.
3. Autumn Falls - The Algorithm Whisperer
September Earnings Estimate: $2.5M+
The Vibe: Next-gen e-girl aesthetics meets data-driven content strategy
Why She’s Rising: Autumn’s TikTok-to-OnlyFans funnel has become the industry standard. Her September growth exploded after a viral dance challenge that converted over 200K new subscribers in the first week alone.
4. Blac Chyna - The Business Mogul
September Earnings Estimate: $2.3M+
The Vibe: Luxury lifestyle meets entrepreneurial wisdom
Why She’s Dominating: Beyond her content, Chyna’s “Creator Academy” launch this month has positioned her as the platform’s business expert. Her premium coaching program ($5K/month) has waiting lists into 2026.
5. Christine Quinn - The Reality Star Revolution
September Earnings Estimate: $2.1M+
The Vibe: High-fashion domination with reality TV drama
Why She’s Breaking Records: Christine’s “Selling Sunset” fanbase has followed her to OnlyFans, where she offers behind-the-scenes luxury real estate content blended with her signature femdom aesthetic.
What These Titans Have in Common
Content Diversification: Each top creator has expanded beyond traditional content into education, coaching, or mainstream media projects.
Cross-Platform Mastery: Their success comes from strategic content teasing on free platforms that drives conversion to paid subscriptions.
Community Building: The highest earners focus on creating exclusive communities rather than just posting content.
Beyond the Top 5: Other September Standouts
While these five dominate the earnings charts, September has seen incredible movement in niche categories:
Who surprised you on this list? Think we missed someone who should be in the September top 5? Join the conversation in the comments below and make your case for next month’s rankings!
Rankings are based on estimated earnings, subscriber growth, social media impact, and industry reports for September 2025. All figures are estimates based on publicly available data.